Yelpless: What kinds of reviews get squelched by Yelp?

In: , ,
Gorgeous Georgia's Yelp listing

Gorgeous Georgia's Yelp listingI’m an ardent (some might say pathological) Yelp user, and since I am incapable of putting anything in my mouth without first validating its viability on Yelp, I try to contribute back to the community by sharing my own perspectives and information, particularly on the all-important subject of artisanal ice cream.

But today I got censored on Yelp for the first time. Last summer, during our family vacation in the Okanagan, I posted this review of Gorgeous Georgia’s Homemade Ice Cream Truck:

Attention: this is not actually ice cream. I somehow missed that when reading the online descriptions. It’s ALL nondairy, coconut-based frozen ice creamesque product. Couldn’t persuade the kids to try it, so I haven’t actually had a real try myself.

Here’s what Yelp says about why they removed it:

We wanted to let you know that we’ve removed your review of Gorgeous Georgia’s Homemade Ice-Cream. Our Support team has determined that it falls outside our Content Guidelines ( because it lacks a firsthand customer experience.

The content guidelines describe “personal experience” as follows:

Personal experience: We want to hear about your firsthand consumer experience, not what you heard from your co-worker or significant other. Try to tell your own story without resorting to broad generalizations and conclusory allegations.

I understand the importance of focusing on reviews that offer personal experience, and I imagine that most of the time, that constitutes direct experience from someone who purchased the product. But I was sharing a personal experience — the personal experience of discovering that, despite the name of the food truck and its place in the “ice cream and yogurt” category, this isn’t actually ice cream. That seems like useful and relevant information for anyone thinking of visiting the food truck, and is certainly information I would have wanted to know beforehand as a Yelp user.

This strikes me as an interesting example of the dilemma social networks face when they depend on advertising rather than subscription revenue (or better yet, a mix of the two). I’d gladly pay as much as $50/year for Yelp, in addition to the effort I put into creating Yelp content, in order to have a site that offers comprehensive information about the businesses and restaurants I may want to patronize. But of course, as an advertiser-supported business, Yelp is in a bind: it depends on retailers not just as content but as sponsors. My assumption, in a case like this, is that the deletion was precipitated by a complaint from Gorgeous Georgia — but of course, I’d love to hear from Yelp or Gorgeous to find out if that hunch is correct.

UPDATE: Gorgeous Georgia tells me via Twitter that the deletion request didn’t come from them, so I’m following up with Yelp. My favorite working theory comes from this comment on my Facebook thread, suggesting I angered a vegan…which we all know is very, very dangerous.

What’s your take? Is this kind of review a useful contribution of “personal experience”, or do you prefer to hear from people who’ve actually made purchases?

2 Comments on this site

  1. Ariane Khachatourians

    Cross-posting my comment from Facebook for posterity:

    Hmm… I’m of two minds on this: A) I think it’s ridiculous they removed that kind of review/comment and B) to a lot of people (who can’t have dairy) the food you describe completely qualifies as “iced cream”. My point being, your review may or may not be something many people would agree with, but that doesn’t mean it should be removed. It’s pretty legit for you to point out that the iced cream is vegan if that’s not being advertised/explicitly said.

  2. A.

    I realize this is an old post, but as a business owner, I wanted to ask you a question:

    What rating did you give this review that was squelched? If you gave them a 5 star rating, the comment shouldn’t bother anyone, as it would just be giving them a head’s up (though Yelp’s algorithm might complain about something).

    However, if you gave the business anything less than a 5 star, you are actually hurting that business, financially and reputation wise, when you have never tasted its product or visited its premises. You seem to be aware of the “bind” as you put it that Yelp is in (never mind the fact that Yelp doesn’t actually do anything a business that pays to advertise requests of them; they are very strict about their TOS) yet most Yelpers who post reviews like this one (I am not accusing you, as I do not know what rating you assigned your review) do so without considering the harm they are doing to the business they are expressing their opinion about.

    Fair is fair: if you have an experience with a business, you have every right to Yelp about it. But when you don’t, maybe wait until you do. Save your review with the helpful tip until after you’ve actually tried the “iced cream” they’re offering. Then, the review you ultimately post will be that much more useful, both to the business and the Yelp community.

    Just 1 cents from someone who lives on both sides of the Yelp world.


  1. Is this an ice cream? A 2x2 - Alexandra Samuel - [...] Yelpless: What kinds of reviews get squelched by Yelp? [...]

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share This